diff --git a/email_handler.py b/email_handler.py
index 469e5675..6673f0d8 100644
--- a/email_handler.py
+++ b/email_handler.py
@@ -476,24 +476,26 @@ def handle_reply(envelope, smtp: SMTP, msg: Message, rcpt_to: str) -> (bool, str
             return False, "550 SL E5"
 
     user = alias.user
-    mailbox_email = alias.mailbox_email()
+    mail_from = envelope.mail_from.lower().strip()
 
     # bounce email initiated by Postfix
     # can happen in case emails cannot be delivered to user-email
     # in this case Postfix will try to send a bounce report to original sender, which is
     # the "reply email"
-    if envelope.mail_from == "<>":
+    if mail_from == "<>":
         LOG.warning(
-            "Bounce when sending to alias %s from %s, user %s",
-            alias,
-            contact.website_email,
-            alias.user,
+            "Bounce when sending to alias %s from %s, user %s", alias, contact, user,
         )
 
         handle_bounce(contact, alias, msg, user)
         return False, "550 SL E6"
 
-    mailbox: Mailbox = Mailbox.get_by(email=mailbox_email)
+    mailbox = Mailbox.get_by(email=mail_from, user_id=user.id)
+    if not mailbox or mailbox not in alias.mailboxes:
+        # only mailbox can send email to the reply-email
+        handle_unknown_mailbox(envelope, msg, reply_email, user, alias)
+        return False, "550 SL E7"
+
     if ENFORCE_SPF and mailbox.force_spf:
         ip = msg[_IP_HEADER]
         if not spf_pass(ip, envelope, mailbox, user, alias, contact.website_email, msg):
@@ -501,13 +503,7 @@ def handle_reply(envelope, smtp: SMTP, msg: Message, rcpt_to: str) -> (bool, str
 
     delete_header(msg, _IP_HEADER)
 
-    # only mailbox can send email to the reply-email
-    if envelope.mail_from.lower() != mailbox_email.lower():
-        handle_unknown_mailbox(envelope, msg, mailbox, reply_email, user, alias)
-        return False, "550 SL E7"
-
     delete_header(msg, "DKIM-Signature")
-
     delete_header(msg, "Received")
 
     # make the email comes from alias
@@ -636,36 +632,33 @@ def spf_pass(
     return True
 
 
-def handle_unknown_mailbox(
-    envelope, msg, mailbox: Mailbox, reply_email: str, user: User, alias: Alias
-):
+def handle_unknown_mailbox(envelope, msg, reply_email: str, user: User, alias: Alias):
     LOG.warning(
         f"Reply email can only be used by mailbox. "
-        f"Actual mail_from: %s. msg from header: %s, Mailbox %s. reply_email %s",
+        f"Actual mail_from: %s. msg from header: %s, reverse-alias %s, %s %s",
         envelope.mail_from,
         msg["From"],
-        mailbox.email,
         reply_email,
+        alias,
+        user,
     )
 
     send_email_with_rate_control(
         user,
         ALERT_REVERSE_ALIAS_UNKNOWN_MAILBOX,
-        mailbox.email,
+        user.email,
         f"Reply from your alias {alias.email} only works from your mailbox",
         render(
             "transactional/reply-must-use-personal-email.txt",
             name=user.name,
-            alias=alias.email,
+            alias=alias,
             sender=envelope.mail_from,
-            mailbox_email=mailbox.email,
         ),
         render(
             "transactional/reply-must-use-personal-email.html",
             name=user.name,
-            alias=alias.email,
+            alias=alias,
             sender=envelope.mail_from,
-            mailbox_email=mailbox.email,
         ),
     )
 
diff --git a/templates/emails/transactional/reply-must-use-personal-email.html b/templates/emails/transactional/reply-must-use-personal-email.html
index 790782ad..356aa1aa 100644
--- a/templates/emails/transactional/reply-must-use-personal-email.html
+++ b/templates/emails/transactional/reply-must-use-personal-email.html
@@ -2,10 +2,27 @@
 
 {% block content %}
   {{ render_text("Hi " + name) }}
-  {{ render_text("We have recorded an attempt to send an email from your alias <b>"+ alias +"</b> using <b>" + sender + "</b>.") }}
-  {{ render_text("Please note that sending from this alias only works from <b>" + mailbox_email + "</b>.") }}
-  {{ render_text("Indeed, only you (or the mailbox that owns <b>" + alias + "</b>) can send emails on behalf of this alias.") }}
-  {{ render_text('Thanks, <br />SimpleLogin Team.') }}
+
+  {% call text() %}
+    We have recorded an attempt to send an email from your alias <b>{{ alias.email }}</b> using <b>{{ sender }}</b>>
+  {% endcall %}
+
+  {% call text() %}
+    Please note that sending from this alias only works from one of these mailboxes: <br>
+    {% for mailbox in alias.mailboxes %}
+      - {{ mailbox.email }} <br>
+    {% endfor %}
+  {% endcall %}
+
+  {% call text() %}
+    Indeed only you can send emails on behalf of your alias.
+  {% endcall %}
+
+  {% call text() %}
+    Thanks, <br/>
+    SimpleLogin Team.
+  {% endcall %}
+
 {% endblock %}
 
 
diff --git a/templates/emails/transactional/reply-must-use-personal-email.txt b/templates/emails/transactional/reply-must-use-personal-email.txt
index 1ee52f1f..21e4b7fe 100644
--- a/templates/emails/transactional/reply-must-use-personal-email.txt
+++ b/templates/emails/transactional/reply-must-use-personal-email.txt
@@ -1,8 +1,15 @@
 Hi {{name}}
 
-We have recorded an attempt to send an email from your alias {{ alias }} using {{ sender }}.
+We have recorded an attempt to send an email from your alias {{ alias.email }} using {{ sender }}.
 
-Please note that sending from this alias only works from {{mailbox_email}}: only you (i.e. no one else) can send emails on behalf of your alias.
+Please note that sending from this alias only works from one of these mailboxes:
+
+{% for mailbox in alias.mailboxes %}
+- {{mailbox.email}}
+{% endfor %}
+
+
+Indeed only you can send emails on behalf of your alias.
 
 Best,
 SimpleLogin team.